Can Borough Firefighters Unionize?

The answer to whether Emmaus Borough Firefighters can form a union awaits a decision from the Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board.

By Jack Tobias

Are Emmaus firefighters borough employees?

That's the issue a Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board hearing officer will have to do decide following a more-than-six-hour hearing Thursday in Harrisburg.

John Pozniak's ruling will impact borough firefighters' efforts to form a union and conduct collective bargaining with Emmaus.

Pozniak said he would issue his ruling at a later date, according to a story in The Morning Call.

Patch took a look at the issue in a story posted Dec. 29.

According to The Call story, some of the players at Thursday's hearing were:
  • An attorney for the Pennsylvania Fire Fighters Association, which has requested permission to represent 27 Emmaus firefighters in collective bargaining with the borough. The attorney -- Matthew Areman of Philadelphia -- said Emmaus firefighters are paid rates set by the borough, have their taxes withheld by the borough, and are issued W2 forms from the borough each year.
  • Borough firefighters Shawn Lubenetski and Troy Raab, who testified on behalf of the fire fighters association.
  • Borough attorneys Jeffrey Dimmich and Thomas Dinkelacker, who said the borough merely distributes a lump sum to the fire department each year to use at its discretion and that Borough Council has no control over the department's operations.
  • Borough manager Shane Pepe, who said in the Patch story that borough firefighters are volunteers, not employees, and thus cannot form a union.
Others points from the Patch story include:
  • The borough already pays some salaries and benefits to fire department personnel. It also provides stipends to encourage volunteer participation. According to 2011 figures provided by the borough, Emmaus paid $423,411 for fire operations, plus $321,581 in salaries and benefits for a total contribution of $744,992. That came to 8.5 percent of the $8.68 million general fund budget.
  • Borough council has introduced a proposed ordinance that would apply to fire department operations.
  • The borough gets state aid for fire department operations in the form of a "foreign fire" tax. The word "foreign" refers to out-of-state companies that provide insurance to in-state properties.
Sheriffchris January 13, 2014 at 12:05 PM
Are they volunteers or are they actual employees. Do they have any of the normal benefits that employees get ? Is there an hourly or daily rate for their service ? The money they received was it SALARY or INCENTIVES ? Many districts have incentive arrangements to keep volunteer membership up. No matter how this comes out, Fire Fighting in Emmaus will never be the same !!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »