The Wednesday Early Dismissal Debate
East Penn School District has implemented early dismissal Wednesdays for decades. Other area districts have not. Are there advantages to this option?
This seems to be a hot topic for many people this week, so I thought I’d chime in.
Having grown up in East Penn School District, Wednesday’s 1:30 p.m. dismissal times seem only natural. It’s the way it’s always been. As a lifelong resident of the district, I never really asked why.
But as a parent, now I also wonder.
When I was a student, Wednesdays were my favorite day of the week. Naturally, it was a shorter school day, which meant less time sitting in the stuffy classroom. But it also meant there was a unique opportunity to visit with friends in the middle of the hectic school week.
Children boarded school buses with notes from parents stating changes in drop-off locations.
“Jeff, please note that Jenae will be getting off the bus with Audrey this afternoon so they can have a play date. Sincerely, Mrs. Wolfe.”
It was a little like having a holiday break every week. I looked forward to Wednesdays with an anticipation similiar to that with which I now look forward to summer vacations.
As soon as one Wednesday afternoon play date was over, I would begin my planning for the following week. Whose house would I go to? What adventure would we embark upon?
It also allowed the opportunity for dentist appointments and other daytime errands, which as a child I didn’t appreciate as much as I do as a parent.
Now that my own children are attending East Penn, my feelings about early dismissal on Wednesdays are mixed. I’m fortunate that I can work from home and have a flexible schedule.
How do you feel about early dismissal Wednesdays in East Penn? Tell us in the comments.
And I do take advantage of those early afternoon appointments.
I’m also fortunate that my in-laws live a block from my children’s school and can assist in crunch times.
It’s actually worked out pretty well for my oldest son to take piano lessons at 2 p.m. on Wednesdays and not interfere with his evening schedule of sports and homework.
But I think back to the year that my oldest was in afternoon kindergarten attending his one-hour school day each Wednesday. It seemed like such a waste of time and gas.
He got on the bus at 12:15 and came home at 1:40. What could possibly be learned in that short hour – especially when factoring in all the logistics of getting on and off the bus, settling into the classroom, etc.
I imagine not a whole lot.
I empathize with the families who have two parents working full-time and for the single parents who don’t have many options. It must be a logistical nightmare.
My husband teaches in Parkland School District where such a schedule doesn’t exist. Regardless of not having half-day Wednesdays, other districts follow a similar yearly school calendar to East Penn and everyone seems to do fine with it.
I wonder if there’s a way we can get everyone on the same page to avoid the frustration that seems to be growing with these differences in scheduling.
Keri Schaadt
1:11 pm on Wednesday, September 5, 2012
Great article, Jenae. I think that a lot has changed since the 70s when this 1/2 day Wednesday program was created. Today, I think there is a greater number of dual parent working households and it truly is a burden for childcare as a number of daycares will not pick up children from school nor will buses alter routes to drop children off at facilities. I chose private school for this reason and for the fear of my child getting PM Kindergarten and only going to school for 1 hour on Wednesdays. I appreciate that teachers have more to do to prepare in this day and age, but I think the practice needs to be reevaluated because our children are missing out on 2 more hours of education and, well, I think they need that extra time if they are going to score the points on the PSSA's that the state is now requiring.
watermantimes5
5:22 pm on Wednesday, September 5, 2012
I personally hate early dismissals on Wednesdays. Even when I was a stay at home mom it interfered with my littler ones that were not in school yet and their nap time. Wednesdays were always cranky days. If other school districts are following the same schedule as East Penn then why are we still letting them out early on Wednesdays. I also am not a big fan of the weeks that are parent teacher conferences and they get out all week long at 1:30...those conferences are only 15 minutes long and I find that they are pretty much time waste. If a child has issues or parents have concerns then they should schedule a conference. I rejoice when my children start middle school because if they have good grades and behavior then I don't waste my time or the teachers time for 15 minutes of "oh you have a wonderful child and they are such a pleasure to have in my classroom". I also get annoyed when the person in front of me takes up my 15 mins too.
Melanie Shimer
9:55 pm on Wednesday, September 5, 2012
I can't believe that the district does this EVERY Wednesday. That is an incredible amount of instructional time! 2 hours a week times a 36 week school year...72 hours that I personally think the kids should be in school...not to mention PM kindergarten on a Wednesday, which is an hour long? I could see an early dismissal once a month, but not each week. I am glad my son is done with elementary school for this reason...just my opinion.
JCK
6:57 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Had I known East Penn schools had early dismissal each Wednesday during the school year, we would not have moved here. There are many reasons why this should not occur and based on these comments, as well as fellow parents in the district that I know, I am not the only one with frustrations. Instead of venting, how can we as tax paying parents change this old policy? Suggestions are appreciated.
mla
11:28 pm on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Individuals need to start attending and speaking up at board meetings. I agree this policy needs to be changed. The children's education should be the District's priority. This policy puts that into question.